$B!!(B $B!!(B $B!!(B $B!!?@8M%l%/%A%c!<(B

$B"#(B$BBh(B10$B2s!J(B2011$BG/!K?@8M5-G0%l%/%A%c!<$N$4Js9p(B NEW!$B!!(B

$B"#(B$BBh(B10$B2s!J(B2011$BG/!K?@8M5-G0%l%/%A%c!<$N$40FFb!!(B

$B"#(B$BBh(B10$B2s!J(B2011$BG/!K?@8M5-G0%l%/%A%c!<$N$40FFb!J5l!K!!(B

$B"#(B$BBh(B9$B2s?@8M%l%/%A%c!<$N8fJs9p(B

$B"#(B$BBh(B9$B2s?@8M%l%/%A%c!<$*$h$S4XO"%;%_%J!<$N$40FFb(B

$B"#(B$B?@8M%l%/%A%c!<4k2hDs0F=qDs=PMW9`(B

$B"#(B$B?@8M%l%/%A%c!<1~Jg35MW(B

$B"#(B$B2a5n$N?@8M%l%/%A%c!<(B

$B"#(B$BBh(B10$B2s?@8M5-G0%l%/%A%c!$B!!(BNEW!
$B!!5n$k(B2011$BG/(B7$B7n!"(BIVR$B!JK!E/3X!&7$-$7$F3+:E$7$^$7$?!#(B
$B!!:#2s$N?@8M5-G0%l%/%A%c!<$G$O!"(B7$B7n(B2$BF|(B($BEZ(B)$B$NEl5~%;%_%J!<$rHi@Z$j$K!"(B7$B7n(B12$BF|(B($B2P(B)$B$N6e=#%;%_%J!<$K;j$k$^$G!"(B2$B=54V$N4V$K7W(B5$B2s$N%l%/%A%c! $B!!!V%0%m!<%P%k$J@55A$H%J%7%g%J%j%F%#(!(!(BDavid Miller, National Responsibility and Global Justice $B$r$a$0$k%7%s%]%8%&%`!W$HLCBG$?$l$?(B7$B7n(B2$BF|$NEl5~%;%_%J!<$G$O!"0f>eC#IW2q0w(B($BEl5~Bg3X(B)$B!"D9C+@n982q0w(B($BKL3$F;Bg3X(B)$B!"@P;3J8I'2q0w(B($BCf1{Bg3X(B)$B!"?@EgM5;R;a(B($BCf1{Bg3X(B)$B$r%3%a%s%F!<%?$K7^$(!"%_%i!<65$B!N$B!#$3$N%7%s%]$G$O!"D9C+@n2q0w$,!"%_%i!<65'$($k(I"$B%M!<%7%g%s$N@UG$(I#$B$H(I"$B%0%m!<%P%k$J@55A(I#$B$H$NO"@\$N2DG=@-$re2q0w$O$3$l$i(B2$B$D$NMWAG4V$N6[D%$,%_%i!<65C$5$l$F$$$J$$$HHcH=$7$^$7$?!#$^$?@P;32q0w$O!"%_%i!<65

20110702kobelec2.jpg


$B!!(B7$B7n(B4$BF|(B($B7n(B)$B$KCf5~Bg3X$G!V%0%m!<%P%k$J@55A!&%0%m!<%P%k;qK\l8E20%;%_%J!<$G$O!"%_%i!<658E20;TN)Bg3X(B)$B!";3CfM%2q0w(B($B9D3X4[Bg3X(B)$B!"1:;3@;;R;a(B($BF|K\3X=Q?66=2q(B)$B$+$i$=$l$>$lJs9p$,$J$5$l!"$=$l$K%_%i!<65l$N@)EY2~3W$N$?$a$N5,HO$G$"$k$He$N!V%J%7%g%J%k$JO"BS?4!W$rMJ8n$9$k$3$H$N@5Ev@-$r2~$a$FLd$$$?$@$7$^$7$?!#(B
$B!!(B7$B7n(B6$BF|(B($B?e(B)$B$K$O!"Bg:e%;%_%J!MN=t9q$K$*$1$k%j%Y%i%k!&%J%7%g%J%j%:%`!W$,!"4X@>Bg3X$G3+:E$5$l$^$7$?!#$3$N%;%_%J!<$G$O!"9'Ci1dIW;a(B($B4X@>Bg3X(B)$B$,%$%s%I7{K!8&5f$NN)>l$+$i!"KYY68yFs;a(B($BF|K\%(%M%k%.!<7P:Q8&5f=j(B)$B$,(BUAE$B8&5f$NN)>l$+$iHs@>MN=t9q$K$*$1$k%j%Y%i%k!&%J%7%g%J%j%:%`$N2DG=@-$rO@$8$?$N$KBP$7!";\8w912q0w(B($B6e=#Bg3X(B)$B$O!"F|K\$K$*$1$k?M8"650i$,8D?M $B!!(B7$B7n(B9$BF|(B($BEZ(B)$B$KF1;Vr7o$O$"$k$N$+!)(I#$B$H$$$&O@Bj$G9V1i$r9T$$!"$=$l$KBP$7$FBm@nM51Q2q0w(B($BBg:e;TN)Bg3X(B)$B!"IYBt9n;a(B($BF1;V$B!N$B!#Bm@n2q0w$OHH:ac$N$"$jJ}$K$D$$$FLd$$$?$@$7!":y0f2q0w$O%_%i!<65




$B!!:#2s$N0lO"$N%;%_%J!<$N:G8e$r>~$C$?$N$O!"6e=#Bg3X$G(B7$B7n(B12$BF|$K3+:E$5$l$?6e=#%;%_%J!3X1!Bg3X(B)$B$O9q2H9T0Y$N=8CD@UG$$r8D?M$KIj2]$9$k:,5r$H$J$k$N$O%M!<%7%g%s$N9=@.0w$G$"$k$3$H$G$J$/L1 $B!!:#2s$N0lO"$N9T;v$K$*$$$F$O!"El5~%;%_%J!<$,Ls(B100$BL>!"5~ET$N%l%/%A%c!<$,Ls(B80$BL>$ND0=0$r=8$a$?$[$+!"=5F|$K3+:E$5$l$?3FCO$N%;%_%J!<$b(B20$BL>!A(B30$BL>$N;22C$l3hH/$J $B!!:#2s$N?@8M5-G0%l%/%A%c!<$NFC?'$N(B1$B$D$O!"B?$/$N]$rM?$($^$7$?!#%_%i!<65 $B!!:G8e$K!":#2s$N0lO"$N%l%/%A%c!l$G$N3+:E$KA4LLE*$K6(NO$7$F$/$@$5$C$??@8M5-G0%l%/%A%c!<l$KB-$r1?$s$G$/$@$5$C$?3'MM$K$"$i$?$a$F8|$/$*Ni$r?=$7>e$2$^$9!#(B

IVR$BF|K\;YItD9!!:y0f!!E0(B

$B!v!!!!!!!v!!!!!!!v(B

$B"#(B$BBh(B10$B2s?@8M5-G0%l%/%A%c!$B!!(B
$B!!(B2011$BG/(B7$B7n$K!"Bh(B10$B2s?@8M5-G0%l%/%A%c!<$,%*%C%/%9%U%)!<%IBg3X%J%U%#!<%k%I!&%+%l%C%8$N%G%$%t%#%C%I!&%_%i!<657$-$7$F9T$o$l$^$9!#:#2s$N0lO"$N%l%/%A%c!$B!!$4>5CN$N$h$&$K!"%_%i!<65l$+$i$Nl $B!!%_%i!<65
  • National Responsibility and Global Justice, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2007. $BIYBt9n!&;\8w91$[$+Lu!X%J%7%g%J%k$J@UG$$H%0%m!<%P%k$J@55A!Y(B($BIw9T
  • Political Philosophy: A Very Short Introduction, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2003. $B;32,N60l$[$+Lu!X@/<#E/3X!Y(B($B4dGH=qE9!"(B2005$BG/(B)$B!#(B
  • (co-edited with Sohail Hashmi) Boundaries and Justice: Diverse Ethical Perspectives, Princeton, Princeton University Press, 2001.
  • Citizenship and National Identity, Cambridge, Polity Press, 2000.
  • Principles of Social Justice, Cambridge, Mass., Harvard University Press, 1999.
  • On Nationality, Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1995. $BIYBt9n!&;\8w91$[$+Lu!X%J%7%g%J%j%F%#$K$D$$$F!Y(B($BIw9T
  • (co-edited with Michael Walzer), Pluralism, Justice and Equality, Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1995.
  • (edited), Liberty, Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1991.
  • Market, State and Community: theoretical foundations of market socialism, Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1989.
  • Anarchism, London, J M Dent & Sons, 1984.
  • Philosophy and Ideology in Hume$B!G(Bs Political Thought, Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1981.
  • Social Justice, Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1976.

  • $B%l%/%A%c!<$d%;%_%J!<$NM=Dj$O!"0J2<$N$h$&$K$J$C$F$$$^$9!#3'MM$N$4;22C$r$*BT$A$7$F$*$j$^$9!#(B
    1. $BEl5~%;%_%J!
      $B%0%m!<%P%k$J@55A$H%J%7%g%J%j%F%#(B "Global Justice and Nationality" -- David Miller, National Responsibility and Global Justice$B$r$a$0$k%7%s%]%8%&%`(B
      $B%Q%M%j%9%H!'0f>eC#IW(B($BEl5~Bg3X65 $BLd9g$;@h!'1':4H~@?!JEl5~9)6HBg3X!K(Busami@soc.titech.ac.jp
      $B:)?F2q;22C$r$44uK>$NJ}$O!"$G$-$k$@$1(B6$B7n(B20$BF|!J7n!K$^$G$K>e5-$NLd9g$;@h$^$G$40lJs2<$5$$!#(B

    2. $BL>8E20%;%_%J!
      $B%0%m!<%P%k$J@55A!&%0%m!<%P%k;qK\l $B%Q%M%j%9%H!'0KF#63I'(B($BL>8E20;TN)Bg3X65 $BLd9g$;@h!'EZ0f?r90!JCf5~Bg3X!K(Bt-doi@mecl.chukyo-u.ac.jp

    3. $BBg:e%;%_%J!Bg3X;yEg0T8,4[(B($BK!3X8&5f=j(B)1$B3,Bh(B1$B2q5D<<(B
      $BHs@>MN=t9q$K$*$1$k%j%Y%i%k!&%J%7%g%J%j%:%`(B "Liberal Nationalism in non-Western Countries"
      $B%Q%M%j%9%H!'9'Ci1dIW(B($B4X@>Bg3X65 $BLd9g$;@h!'3QEDLTG7!J4X@>Bg3X!K(Bttsunoda@ipcku.kansai-u.ac.jp

    4. $B?@8M5-G0%l%/%A%c!
      $B?M8"$N5}r7o$O$"$k$N$+!)(B"Are Human Rights Conditional?"
      $B%3%a%s%F!<%?!'Bm@nM51Q(B($BBg:e;TN)Bg3X65 $BLd9g$;@h!'Fa?\9L2p!J@]FnBg3X!K(Bnasu@law.setsunan.ac.jp

    5. $B6e=#%;%_%J!
      $B?M8"!&%7%F%#%:%s%7%C%W!&%J%7%g%J%j%F%#(B "Human Rights, Citizenship, and Nationality"
      $B%Q%M%j%9%H!'@n@%5.G7(B($B@iMUBg3X=u65(B)$B!"Gr@n=S2p(B($BF|K\3X=Q?66=2qFCJL8&5f0w(B)$B!"1sF#CN;R(B($B4X@>3X1!Bg3X=u65(B)$B!"O!8+FsO:(B($B6e=#Bg3X=Z65 $BLd9g$;@h!';\8w91!J6e=#Bg3X!K(Bse@scs.kyushu-u.ac.jp
      $B:)?F2q;22C$r$44uK>$NJ}$O!"$G$-$k$@$1(B7$B7n(B6$BF|(B($B?e(B)$B$^$G$K>e5-$NLd9g$;@h$^$G$40lJs$/$@$5$$!#(B
    $B%;%_%J!

    $B!v!!!!!!!v!!!!!!!v(B

    $B"#(B$BBh(B10$B2s!J(B2011$BG/!K?@8M5-G0%l%/%A%c!<$N$40FFb!!(B

    $B!!K!E/3X2q2qJs(B22$B9f$G$b$*CN$i$;$7$^$7$?$h$&$K!"Bh(B10$B2s?@8M5-G0%l%/%A%c!<$,!"(B2011$BG/(B7$B7n$K!"%*%C%/%9%U%)!<%IBg3X%J%U%#!<%k%I!&%3%l%C%8$N%G%$%t%#%C%I!&%_%i!<657$-$7$F9T$o$l$^$9!#%_%i!<65
    $B!!!!(B7$B7n(B 2$BF|!JEZ!KEl5~%;%_%J!l!'(B$BEl5~9)6HBg3X(B$B!K(B$BL@<#3X1!Bg3X$KJQ99$K$J$j$^$7$?(B
    $B!!!!(B7$B7n(B 4$BF|!J7n!KL>8E20%;%_%J!l!'Cf5~Bg3X!K(B
    $B!!!!(B7$B7n(B 6$BF|!J?e!KBg:e%;%_%J!l!'4X@>Bg3X!K(B
    $B!!!!(B7$B7n(B 9$BF|!JEZ!K5~ET%l%/%A%c!l!'F1;V $B!!!!(B7$B7n(B12$BF|!J2P!K6e=#%;%_%J!l!'6e=#Bg3X!K(B

    $B!!$4>5CN$N$h$&$K!"%_%i!<65l$+$i$Nl $B!!K.Lu$H$7$F$O!"IYBt9n!&;\8w91$[$+Lu!X%J%7%g%J%j%F%#$K$D$$$F!Y(B($BIw9T $B!!%l%/%A%c!<$d%;%_%J!<$N>\:Y$K$D$$$F$O!"DI$C$F!"(BIVR$BF|K\;YIt$N%&%'%V!&%5%$%H$*$h$SK\3X2qJsEy$rDL$8$F2q0w3F0L$K$*CN$i$;$7$^$9!#3'MM$N@Q6KE*$J$4;22C$r$*4j$$$$$?$7$^$9!#(B

    IVR$BF|K\;YItD9!!:y0f!!E0(B

    $BO"Mm@h!'(BIVR$BF|K\;YIt;vL36I(B
    $B")(B154-8525$B!!El5~ET@$EDC+6h6pBt(B1-23-1
    $B6p_7Bg3XK!3XIt!!9b66MN>k8&5f<<5$IU(B
    Tel$B!'(B03(3418)9206$B!JD>!K!!(BE-mail: hirokit@komazawa-u.ac.jp

    $B!v!!!!!!!v!!!!!!!v(B


    $B"#(B $BBh(B9$B2s?@8M%l%/%A%c!<$N8fJs9p(B

    $B!!5n$k(B2008$BG/(B6$B7n(B7$BF|!"(B8$BF|!"(B9$BF|$K@D;33X1!Bg3X!"Fn;3Bg3X!"5~ETBg3X$K$*$-$^$7$F!"%-%c%9!&(BR$B!&%5%s%9%F%#!<%s657$-$7$F!VBh(B9$B2s?@8M%l%/%A%c!
    $B!!$^$:$O!"=`Hw$de$2$^$9!#$^$?!"EvF|%3%a%s%F!<%?!<$r$*L3$a$$$?$@$$$?=t@h@8J}$r$O$8$a!"$4;22C!&$4D09V$/$@$5$C$?J}!9$K$b!"?4$+$i8fNi$r?=$7>e$2$^$9!#$^$?$H$j$o$1!":#2s$N%l%/%A%c!l$H:5~ETBg3XBg3X1!K!3X8&5f2J658E20!&5~ET$N%;%_%J!<$K$D$-$^$7$F$Oe$2$^$9!#(B

    $B!!El5~%l%/%A%c!<$G$O!"%5%s%9%F%#!<%s@h@8$h$j!V;JK!%_%K%^%j%:%`$rD6$($F!W$H$$$&%F!<%^$G$49V1i$$$?$@$-!"1':4H~@?;a!JEl5~9)6HBg3X!K!"D9C+It63CK;a!JEl5~Bg3X!K$+$i$N%3%a%s%H$N8e!"%U%m%"$b8r$($F3hH/$J8E20%;%_%J!<$G$OF1$8%F!<%^$K4p$E$-!"Bg20M:M5;a!JL>8E20Bg3X!K!"Bm@nM51Q;a!JBg:e;TN)Bg3X!K!"Bg?9=(?C;a!J2,;3Bg3X!K!">>Hx!!M[;a!J5~ETBg3X8&5f0w!K$+$i$=$l$>$l%3%a%s%H$r$$$?$@$-!"%5%s%9%F%#!<%s@h@8$+$i>\:Y$J1~Ez$rD:BW$7$D$DG.$N$3$b$C$?F$O@$,9T$o$l$^$7$?!#(B

    $B!!$5$i$K5~ET%;%_%J!<$K$*$-$^$7$F$O!"!V%j%P%?%j%"%s!&%Q%?!<%J%j%:%`!W$H$$$&
    $B!!$$$:$l$N2q>l$K$*$-$^$7$F$bM=A[$r$O$k$+$K>e2s$k$4;22C$r$$$?$@$-!"$^$?$-$o$a$F?e=`$N9b$$F$O@$,8r$o$5$l$?$3$H$G!"$?$$$X$s=<
    $B!!%5%s%9%F%#!<%s@h@8$K$*$+$l$^$7$F$O!"$4B?K;$N$J$+Hs>o$K%?%$%H$J%9%1%8%e!<%k$H$J$C$F$7$^$C$?$K$b$+$+$o$i$:!"$I$N2q>l$G$b$*Hh$l$NMM;R$R$H$D8+$;$k$3$H$J$/@:NOE*$+$D:Y$d$+$J$*?48/$$$r$b$C$F9V1i!&1~Ez$K]$r;D$7$?$3$H$HB8$8$^$9!#%5%s%9%F%#!<%s@h@8$N:#8e$N$43hLv!"$^$?F|K\$H$N8rN.$N$5$i$J$k?<$^$j$r5'G0$7$D$D!"@.8yN"$K=*N;$$$?$7$^$7$?Bh(B9$B2s?@8M%l%/%A%c!
    $B!!e$2$^$9!#(B

    IVR$BF|K\;YItD9!!3QED!!LTG7!J4X@>Bg3X!K(B

    $B"#(B$BBh#92s?@8M%l%/%A%c!<$*$h$S4XO"%;%_%J!<$N$40FFb!J=*N;!K(B

    $B!!(B1987$BG/$K?@8M$G3+$+$l$?(BIVR$B!JK!E/3X!&
    $B!!:#2s$O!"%"%a%j%+9g=09q$h$j%-%c%9!&(BR$B!&%5%s%9%F%#%s657$-$7!"@D;33X1!Bg3X$K$F9V1i$r3+:E$$$?$7$^$9!#$^$?!"4XO"4k2h$H$7$F!"Fn;3Bg3X$*$h$S5~ETBg3X$K$*$$$F!"%;%_%J!<$rl$HLL$K$o$?$k$46(NO!&$4;Y1g$r$$$?$@$$$F$*$j$^$9!#8|$/8fNi?=$7>e$2$^$9!#(B

    $B!!$4B?K;$N@^$H$OB8$8$^$9$,!"$I$&$+K|>c$*7+$j9g$o$;$N$&$(!"$4;22C$$$?$@$-$^$9$h$&$40FFb?=$7>e$2$^$9!#(B

    IVR$BF|K\;YItD9!!3QED!!LTG7!J4X@>Bg3X!K(B



    $B9V1i$B%-%c%9!&(BR$B!&%5%s%9%F%#%s65Prof. Cass. R. Sunstein)

    $B"'7P!!Nr!'!!(B1954$BG/@8$^$l!#(B1978$BG/$K%O!<%t%!!<%IBg3X%m!<%9%/!<%k$rB46H8e!"(B1980$BG/$^$G%^%5%A%e!<%;%C%D=#:G9b:[H==j%Y%s%8%c%_%s!&%+%W%i%sH=;v$NK!L3=q5-$*$h$SO"K.:G9b:[H==j%5!<%0%C%I!&%^!<%7%c%kH=;v$NK!L3=q5-$rNrG$!#$=$N8e!"9g=09q;JK!>J$N(BThe Office of Legal Council$B$K6PL3$7$F!"%&%/%i%$%J$d%]!<%i%s%I!"Cf9q!"Fn%"%U%j%+!"%m%7%"$J$IB?$/$N9q$N7{K!@)Dj$HK!N'2~3W3hF0$K7H$o$C$?!#(B1981$BG/$h$j%7%+%4Bg3X%m!<%9%/!<%k$N=u65Karl N. Llewellyn Professor$B!"(B1993$BG/$+$i$O(BKarl N. Llewellyn Distinguished Service Professor of Jurisprudence$B!#%3%m%s%S%"Bg3X%m!<%9%/!<%k$H%O!<%t%!!<%IBg3X%m!<%9%/!<%k$N5R0w65
    $B"'6H!!@S!'!!Cx=q$O!"(BAfter the Rights Revolution (1990), The Partial Constitution (1993), Democracy and the Problem of Free Speech (1993), Legal Reasoning and Political Conflict (1996), Free Markets and Social Justice (1997), Administrative Law and Regulatory Policy (1998) (with Justice Stephen Breyer and Professor Richard Stewart and Matthew Spitzer), One Case At A Time (1999), Behavioral Law and Economics (editor, 2000), Designing Democracy (2001), Republic.com (2001), Risk and Reason (2002), The Cost-Benefit State (2002), Punitive Damages (2002), Why Societies Need Dissent (2003), The Second Bill of Rights (2004), Laws of Fear(2005), Radicals in Robes (2005), Are Judges Political ? (2005), Infotopia (2006)$B$[$+B??t!#K.Lu$K$O!"M->>98!a(B $BLxBtOBIW!a;fC+2m;RLu!X<+M3;T>l$HFree Markets and Social Justice$B$NK]Lu!K!"@P@n9,7{Lu!X%$%s%?!<%M%C%H$OL1Republic.com$B$NK]Lu!K$[$+$,$"$k!#(B



    $BEl!!5~!!(B2008$BG/(B6$B7n(B7$BF|!JEZ!K(B14:00$B!A(B17:30
    $B?@8M%l%/%A%c!Beyond Judicial Minimalism
    $B!L2q(B $B>l!M!!@D;33X1!Bg3X@D;3%-%c%s%Q%9(B $BAm8&%S%kBh#1#92q5D<<(B $B!J%-%c%s%Q%9%^%C%W$O(B$B$3$A$i(B$B!K(B
    $B!L9V(B $B;U!M!!%-%c%9!&(BR$B!&%5%s%9%F%#!<%s65$B!L%3%a%s%F!<%?!$B!L$B!L8e(B $B1g!M!!2J3X8&5fHqJd=u6b!J3X=QAO@.8&5fHq!K%]%9%H9=B$2~3W$K$*$1$k;T>l$H$B!L$*Ld$$9g$o$;!M!!2O8+!!@?!J@D;33X1!=w;RC;4|Bg3X!K(Bkawami@luce.aoyama.ac.jp
    $B"((B18:00$B$h$j:)?F2q$r9T$$$^$9!#>l=j!'@D3X2q4[(B



    $BL>8E20!!(B2008$BG/(B 6$B7n(B8$BF|!JF|!K(B14:00$B!A(B17:00
    $B%;%_%J!Beyond Judicial Minimalism
    $B!L2q(B $B>l!M!!Fn;3Bg3XL>8E20%-%c%s%Q%9(B $B#JEo#13,FCJL9gF18&5f<<(B $B!J%-%c%s%Q%9%^%C%W$O(B$B$3$A$i(B$B!K(B
    $B!L9V(B $B;U!M!!%-%c%9!&(BR$B!&%5%s%9%F%#!<%s65$B!L%3%a%s%F!<%?!8E20Bg3X!K!"Bm@nM51Q;a!JBg:e;TN)Bg3X!K!">>Hx!!M[;a!J5~ETBg3X8&5f0w!K(B
    $B!Ll$H$B!L8e(B $B1g!M!!(BIVR$BF|K\;YIt!"F|K\K!E/3X2q(B
    $B!L$*Ld$$9g$o$;!M!!9b66(B $B9-


    $B5~!!ET!!(B2008$BG/(B6$B7n(B9$BF|!J7n!K(B14:00$B!A(B17:00
    $B%;%_%J!Libertarian Paternalism
    $B!L2q(B $B>l!M!!5~ETBg3X5HED%-%c%s%Q%9(B $BI4<~G/;~7WBf5-G04[#23,9q:]8rN.%[!<%k(B? $B!J%-%c%s%Q%9%^%C%W$O(B$B$3$A$i(B$B!K(B
    $B!L9V(B $B;U!M!!%-%c%9!&(BR.$B!&%5%s%9%F%#!<%s65 $B!L%3%a%s%F!<%?!$B!Ll$H$B!L8e(B $B1g!M!!(BIVR$BF|K\;YIt!"F|K\K!E/3X2q!"F1;V$B!L$*Ld$$9g$o$;!M!!3X=QAO@.8&5f;Y1g<$B%[!<%`%Z!<%8(B http://kaken.law.kyoto-u.ac.jp/gakuso/
    $B"((B18:00$B$h$j%l%;%W%7%g%s$r7s$M$?0U8+8r492q$r9T$$$^$9!#2q>l!'F1;V

    $B"(%l%/%A%c!


    $B"#(B$B?@8M%l%/%A%c!<4k2hDs0F=qDs=PMW9K(B

    $B!!#1!%4k2hDs0F=q$K5-:\$9$k9`L\(B
    $B!J(B1$B!K9V;UM=Dj$B!!!!(B?$B9V;UM=Dj!&=jB0!&N,Nr!&6H@SL\O?(B
    $B!!!!(B?$B?@8M%l%/%A%c!<9V;U$H$7$F>7f[$9$k0U5A(B
    $B!!!!(B?$B9V;UM=Dj$B!!!!(B?$B$B!J(B2$B!K9V1i$b$7$/$O%;%_%J!<$NM=DjCO$*$h$SM=DjF|(B
    $B!J(B3$B!K$B!!!!(B?$BE}3g@UG$!&=jB0(B
    $B!!!!(B?$BJ#?t$N9V1i$b$7$/$O%;%_%J!<$,9T$o$l$k>l9g!"$=$l$>$l$K$D$$$F$N$B!!!!@UG$!&=jB0(B
    $B!J(B4$B!KM=A[$5$l$k<}F~$*$h$S;Y=P$NFbLu(B
    $B!!!!(BIVR$B?@8M4p6b$+$i$N;Y=P$O(B80$BK|1_0JFb$H$J$k$h$&$K4k2h$7!"Am;Y=P$,$3$l$rD62a$9$k>l9g$K$O!"30It$N=u@.6b$N?=@A@h!&?=@A3[$r4^$a$?;q6b7W2h$rDs<($7$F$/$@$5$$!J$J$*!"$3$NE@$K4X$7$F$4ITL@$N>l9g$K$OF|K\;YIt;vL36I$^$G$*Ld$$9g$o$;$/$@$5$$!K!#(B

    $B#2!%Ds=PJ}K!(B
    e-mail$B$K$h$k(B

    $B#3!%Ds=P@h(B / $BLd$$9g$o$;@h(B
    IVR$BF|K\;YIt;vL36I!'(B
    $B")(B572-8508$B!!Bg:eI\?220@n;TCSEDCfD.(B17-8$B!!(B
    $B@]FnBg3XK!3XIt!!Fa?\9L2p8&5f<Tel$B!'(B072(839)9310$B!JD>!K(BFax$B!'(B072(838)6636
    E-mail: nasu@law.setsunan.ac.jp

    $B#4!%Dy@Z(B
    $B?@8M%l%/%A%c!<3+:EG/!J#2#0#2#0G/$^$G$N3+:EG/!'#0#8G/!"#1#1G/!"#1#4G/!"#1#7G/!"#2#0G/!K$NA0G/$N#67nKvF|(B


    $B"#(B$B?@8M%l%/%A%c!<1~JgMW9`(B

    $B!J#1!K>7f[$9$k3XEY$HI>2A$rF@$F$*$j!">7f[$K$h$k$o$,9q$NK!E/3X8&5f $B!J#2!K#I#V#R#8#7?@8M4p6b$+$i$N;Y=P$O(B80$BK|1_$r>e8B$H$9$k(B
    $B!J#3!K>7f[9V;U$NEO9RHq!"BZ:_Hq$O86B'$H$7$F30It;q6b!J3FBg3X$b$7$/$O3X=Q?66=2q309q?M8&5f7f[%W%m%0%i%`Ey$r4^$`!K$+$i;Y=P$9$k(B
    $B!J#4!K=t!9$N:bCD$N>7f[%W%m%0%i%`Ey!"30It;q6b$K1~Jg$9$k$h$&$KEX$a$k(B
    $B!J#5!KAH?%0Q0wD9$K2C$($F!"0Q0wD9$N=jB0Bg3X0J30$NBg3X$K=jB0$9$k?tL>$N $B!J#6!K $B!!(B